THIRTY-FOUR
BISHOP’S IS PACKED with people.
It’s only been two days since my meeting with Agatha, and the coffee shop is nowhere near finished—half the equipment hasn’t even been delivered—but after the less-than-successful Welcome! muffins, Mom insisted on throwing a soft opening for the residents, complete with free coffee and baked goods.
She beams and serves and chats, and even though she’s operating at her suspiciously bright full-wattage, she does seem happy. Dad talks coffee with three or four men, leads them behind the counter to see the new grinding machine Mom broke down and got for him. A trio of kids, Jill among them, sits on the patio, dangling their legs in the sun and sipping iced drinks, sharing a muffin between them. A little girl at a corner table doodles on a paper mat with blue crayons. Mom only ordered blue. Ben’s favorite. Ms. Angelli admires the red stone rose set in the floor. And, miracle of miracles, Nix’s chair is pulled up to a table on the patio, my copy of the Inferno in his lap as he flicks ash onto a low edge when Betty looks away. The place is brimming.
And all the while, I cling to the four words—Wesley Ayers is alive—because I still haven’t seen him. The Archive is still closed and my list is still blank, and all I have are those four words and Agatha’s warning buzzing around in my head.
“Mackenzie Bishop!”
Lyndsey launches herself at me, throws her arms around my neck, and I stagger back, wincing. Beneath my long sleeves and my apron, I am a web of bruises and bandages. I could hide most of the damage from my parents, but not the wrist. I claimed it was a bad fall on one of my runs. It wasn’t one of my strongest lies, but I am so tired of lying. Lyndsey is still hugging me. With my ring on, she sounds like rain and harmony and too-loud laughter, but the noise is worth it, and I don’t pull back or push away.
“You came,” I say, smiling. It feels good to smile.
“Duh. Nice apron, by the way,” she says, gesturing to the massive B on its front. “Mom and Dad are around here somewhere. And good job, Mrs. Bishop, this place is full!”
“Free caffeine and sugar, a recipe for making friends,” I say, watching my mother flit between tables.
“You’ll have to give me a proper tour later—Hey, is that Guyliner?”
She cocks her head toward the patio doors, and everything stops.
His eyes are tired, his skin a touch too pale, but he’s there with his spiked hair and his black-rimmed eyes and his hands buried in his pockets. And then, as if he can feel my eyes on him, Wes finds my gaze across the room, and beams.
“It is,” I say, my chest tightening.
But rather than cross the crowded café, Wes nods once in the direction of the lobby and walks out.
“Well, go on, then,” says Lynds, pushing me with a giggle. “I’ll serve myself.” She leans across the counter, swipes a cookie.
I pull off the apron, tossing it to Lyndsey as I trail Wes through the lobby—where more people are milling about with coffee—down the hall and past the study and out into the garden. When we reach the world of moss and vine, he stops and turns, and I throw my arms around him, relishing the drums and the bass and the metal rock as they wash over me, blotting out the pain and guilt and fear and blood of the last time we touched. We both wince but hold on. I listen to the sound of him, as strange and steady as a heartbeat, and then I must have tightened my grip, because he gasps and says, “Gently, there,” and braces himself against the back of a bench, one palm gingerly against his stomach. “I swear, you’re just looking for excuses to get your hands on me.”
“You caught me,” I say, closing my eyes when they start to burn. “I’m so sorry,” I say into his shirt.
He laughs, then hisses in pain. “Hey, don’t be. I know you can’t help yourself.”
I laugh tightly. “I’m not talking about the hug, Wes.”
“Then what are you apologizing for?”
I pull back and look him in the eyes. “For everything that happened.” His brow creases, and my heart sinks.
“Wes,” I say slowly, “you do remember, don’t you?”
He looks at me, confused. “I remember making a date to hunt with you. Nine sharp.” He eases himself onto the stone bench. “But to be honest, I don’t remember anything about the next day. I don’t remember being stabbed. Patrick said that’s normal. Because of trauma.”
Everything aches as I sink down onto the bench beside him. “Yeah…”
“What should I remember, Mac?”
I sit and stare at the stones that make up the garden floor.
Knowledge is power, but ignorance can be a blessing.
Maybe Agatha is right. I think of that moment in the stacks when Roland told me about altering, when he warned me what happened to those who failed and were dismissed. That moment when I hated him for telling me, when I wished I could go back. But there is no going back.
So can’t we just go forward?
I don’t want to hurt Wes anymore. I don’t want to cause him pain, make him relive the betrayal. And after Agatha’s unfriendly meeting, I have no desire to disobey the Archive. But what sets me over the edge is the fact that there, in my mind, louder than all those other thoughts, is this:
I don’t want to confess.
I don’t want to confess because I don’t want to remember. But Wesley doesn’t have that choice, and the only reason he’s missing that time is because of me.
The truth is a messy thing, but I tell it.
We sit in the garden as the day stretches out, and I tell him everything. The easy and the hard. He listens, and frowns, and doesn’t interrupt, except to punctuate with a small “Oh” or “Wow” or “What?”
And after all of it, when he finally speaks, the only thing he says is, “Why couldn’t you come to me?”
I’m about to tell him about Roland’s orders, but that’s only a partial truth, so I start again.
“I was running away.”
“From what?”
“I don’t know. The Archive. That life. This. Ben. Me.”
“What’s so wrong with you?” he asks. “I quite like you.” And then, a moment later, he adds, “I just can’t believe I lost to a skinny blond guy with a knife.”
I laugh. Pain ripples through me, but it’s worth it. “It was a very big knife,” I say.
Silence settles over us. Wes is the one to break it.
“Hey,” he says.
“Hey.”
“Are you going to be okay?”
I close my eyes. “I don’t know, Wes. Everything hurts. I don’t know how to make it stop. It hurts when I breathe. It hurts when I think. I feel like I’m drowning, and it’s my fault, and I don’t know how to be okay. I don’t know if I can be okay. I don’t know if I should be allowed to be okay.”
Wesley knocks his shoulder against mine.
“We’re a team, Mac,” he says. “We’ll get through this.”
“Which part?” I ask.
He smiles. “All of it.”
And I smile back, because I want him to be right.